I.
Introduction - Gravity (2013), Alfonso Cuaron, Sandra Bullock, George Clooney
II. Thesis - Gravity is a movie that centers around the
physics of deep space, but at its core,
it is a movie, and a movie tells a story. Although the movie often breaks Newton's first law of motion (any
object in motion will remain in motion unless acted
upon by another force), it does so to further the action and continue the story.
III. Body
1. Dr. Bryan Stone is hurled away into
space. She tumbles and spins, but eventually
slows down.
A. In space, there is no
air resistance, and no friction, so Dr. Stone should have continued spinning and tumbling
until she encountered another force.
B. Despite how the
physics was wrong, audience was not pulled out of the moment because Dr. Stone did not come to a complete
stop, instead she slowed down
spinning enough to be rescued by Matt Kowalski.
This was a choice to further the
action in a believable although false way.
2. Dr. Stone is tethered to a heavy
object, and she catches a free flying Matt Kowalski,
but his momentum keeps pulling him away from Stone.
A. There is a scene that
accurately portrays what should have happened. Kowalski
has Stone tethered to himself as he uses a thruster pack to propel himself through space. Kowalski moves and
changes direction, which jerks Stone
to and fro.
- Stone is continuing to move in one direction, but once
Kowalski changes direction, she
experiences an abrupt jerk because she must change
direction as well.
B. The decision was made
to somehow have Kowalski's momentum carry him away
from Stone despite the fact that her efforts should have pulled him towards her, in order to heighten suspense
and tension.
3. When Stone removes her helmet
inside of the space station and she is floating in
zero gravity, her hair stays flat on her head as if she were on earth.
A. There is a
scene that accurately portrays how her hair should have behaved. Stone begins to cry and when her tears
leave her eyes, they float away, along with
other miscellaneous objects that are not strapped down.
B. This is a
detail problem that could take viewers out of the moment.
IV. Conclusion - Whenever the movie breaks Newton's First
Law, it is for the sake of furthering
the plot, or creating tension and suspense. At times Newton's First Law may be broken by an apparent lack of
attention to detail, however, in consideration
of how well done the rest of the movie is, this minor detail can be overlooked. Overall, the movie accurately
portrays a sense of claustrophobia and
oppression in space, where if an object is in motion, it will continue forever and ever unless it comes into contact
with another force.
No comments:
Post a Comment